There was reasoning behind it (albeit not that great), and its been resolved. Emma wasn't forgiven immediately either, but being forced to live with each other sped up the process a bit. Its a game and its never going to be realistic, that's what makes it a good game. I think this is all just a misunderstanding and can be resolved rather quickly. If you don't like a character then you don't like a character, but that's no reason to hate the game. I do advise playing through the whole game before writing bad reviews on it. Hopefully you will play through the game and realize its potential for what it is. I personally love this game, and my least favorite character is Emma, but she isn't a bad character, and has a very complex story behind her, that may be hard for others to understand. I really hope you finish playing and enjoy this game, even if its just because of Serena and Berry.