I like the point-and-click adventure feel of this one. You had some really good one-liners. I laughed really hard at the line "As if I would take some stranger's bucket" since stealing a bucket was the very first thing I added to my game.
I found a big bug: One of the fights (bat?) wasn't ending correctly when I failed. It just kept destroying the items I tried while continuing the battle. It could soft-lock the game if someone lost an item they need later, and saved after the battle.
Other than that it was just minor things: Some tile passibility. The downward walking animation has some pixels clipping from another frame (I'm guessing that came from the sprite generator?). I also struggled with remembering to double check things I already searched, even though I read the notes at the beginning. I was stuck the longest looking for those dang rocks!
Overall, I had fun. Congrats on finishing your first RPG Maker game, and your first game jam!