That's no good. I'll have to take a look at it today. Thanks for letting me know!
In the meantime, I can say with some certainty that it sounds like an issue with the save system, as it should say "Start" when you first play, not "Continue." If you go into the settings, does it offer you to delete your save? If it offers for you to delete, maybe try clicking that and running again. Might be a quick and dirty fix to whatever you're experiencing, in case I'm not able to figure what's actually going on with any sort of speediness.
Sorry for the inconvenience. Best case scenario, I'll figure what you've got going on pretty quick and upload a fixed version (I believe this is allowed by jam rules).