Update #2: I was searching the community tab to see if someone else had their games deleted and was trying to get them reuploaded when I found this post: https://itch.io/t/1499512/ive-accidentally-deleted-my-itchio-game-and-page-i-nee...
In the post Leafo says "It’s actually possible to restore a deleted page. Deleted files are permanently gone the second you delete them though." This is the exact case I am in. I have all the files on the USB so I can reupload them, I am just looking to restore the pages and comments of the games. Hopefully I can get something worked out with support to get the pages back.