Yes, lighter was off but torches was on. I basically got used to the pattern of seeing where they grey/white ghosts were, but sometimes they wouldn't show up but the red-eyed girl would still spawn as if I had walked into them.
Viewing post in Through the Catacombs jam comments
Ah I know the issue, I'll fix that a bit later xD Basically the ghosts visibility is tied to the lighter being turned on or off (This was so they couldn't be seen when the lighter is deactivated since they have a emission glow on the shader material. I'll get that and some more stuff fixed later! Thanks for the help :)