I also understand that this is a particular problem of yours and not a general problem of the community that uses Itch.
I also understand that you can solve it without any problem on your own, so I don't see the need to implement something like that, which, as you were told, could be uncomfortable for many users.
If a large user base had the same problem, I think a change like that is justified, but if not, I don't see the point either.
In the years that I have been using itch, I have never had that problem.
In any case, the decision to implement it or not is up to the administration and for what they can see and process accordingly, I think this post would go better in the suggestions subforum instead of the questions subforum.