First game? 15 years old? AMAZING! Great work. Keep it up.
I liked the game, and loved the concept. The different candles and colours to reveal different platforms was a great idea. And the puzzle ideas it offers up are cool, and you made some great decisions in that regard.
I did find the controls very unintuitive. I think there's a better way to switch between candles that feels more natural. Maybe use the mouse to click the candle you want to light up or something? Just so the player can see the controls instead of thinking about the controls.
Other than that though, awesome game concept. I played right through to the end. I did just guess where the platforms were a couple of times, but I liked that part. It made it feel like there were more ways to solve the puzzle and I felt clever. Nice work.
Cheers, hope to see more games from you!
- D