Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags

This is a very good idea, kind of similar to The Incredible Machine (a game I loved in my childhood), but some basic aspects of the design stop this from being compelling for me.

Firstly, having a message tell me upfront that some of the puzzles might not be solvable is rather demotivating, and if that’s true, you probably ought to fix that. The simplest way is to move away from the random generation aspect and hand-design puzzles.

Secondly, I didn’t like that I couldn’t retry any given puzzle. To compare to The Incredible Machine (the game this reminds me of), that game lets you run and reset any given puzzle as many times as you need to, and the way I used to play that game was to start by seeing what happens if I did nothing, then decide from there what exactly I should do to achieve the goal. Here, I’m instead expected to just guess what arrangement of things might lead to a solution, try it once, and then give up, which is further demotivation on top of already feeling demotivated not knowing if there’s a solution at all.

The idea is there, and it’s a good one with a lot of potential, so if you are at all inclined to develop it further after the jam is over, I would highly encourage it.

Hi, thanks for the comment. I knew that this idea was risky, because not every player likes to find their own solution to problems with what they get, but for me it's amazing. I understand your point, but if I premade the levels it wouldn't have charm, because the core concept is randomness and improvisation (heavily inspired by Mosa Lina).

If you are playing normal mode, it consists on beating five given levels (and I should've marked that) that are chosen randomly. The levels repeat until you beat them (a thing that I also should've marked).

Anyway, thanks for the feedback and for dedicating your time to writing it.

PS:All levels are all possible, but rarely you have a loadout that doesn't work for the given scenario.

That’s perfectly valid, and I’m glad you made a game that you like to play! I should clarify, improvising solutions isn’t something I dislike in principle. Actually, some amount of that is found in The Incredible Machine. It’s more the perception that I might be handed an impossible puzzle (informed by the text in the instructions) and the fact that as far as I could tell I couldn’t just retry the same puzzle with tweaks made to my setup.

If indeed it’s generally possible to beat a level, I’d highly recommend you just get rid of the note that it might be impossible. If there’s a rare chance of something not working, I’d consider that to be a bug and try to work on solutions to that, rather than warning the player about it.

I’m not sure what you mean when you say that the levels repeat until you beat them. Looking again, I noticed that clicking the “Give Up” button in normal mode over and over again seemed to randomly switch between a couple different basic puzzle templates with randomly distributed objects. I assume the “levels” you’re referring to are those templates? But from my perspective, this is effectively randomly generated puzzles that you can’t repeat. For example, suppose I come up with a solution that’s very close to succeeding, but not quite; I’d like to be able to repeat from where I set it exactly, adjust further, and see if that leads to a solution. Unless there’s some button I didn’t find other than the “Give Up” button, that doesn’t seem to be possible currently.