The results are in and they are very close! The overall winners weren't based on Itch's ratings (that wasn't really a factor). The deciding factor for me was the theme and how closely it matched it, with the narrative and game design being secondary.
WINNER: Kailun (Knifish)
RUNNER-UP: ingenoire
I'd also like to honorably mention SearedSquawker and add them as 2nd RUNNER-UP with the prize being a pre-release key for my soon-to-be-released Market Pack (if interested).
Thank you once again to all who submitted. In my opinion, everyone who submitted is still a winner in my books!
(This will be the last game jam I host for awhile, but I'm sure others will host some, including AmalgamAsh's Year Long Game Jam.)