Clever rubber duck usage *wink*
Gavengelthegrim
Recent community posts
The game reminded me of Funeralopolis: Last Days if it was crossed with a hint of old-school survival horror.
I would recommend getting rid of the robotic voice acting. It's commonly used and absolutely never lands for me. Just kills immersion which would otherwise be preserved well enough with the captions that are already present.
The remaining criticisms I could've had were already addressed by Niven Hedinger.
Some additional specifics:
The now hidden adult tags will circumvent the filter, in case you did not know. If you select tags like "adult", you will see such games, even if your account's settings are to not show them. They removed the adult tags from the suggestion box as a fix for the obvious issues this presents.
No, I wasn't aware. That's good to know.
And you typically can recognise them and avoid them at a glance.
Yup, I do, do that.
Feel free to check what age rating it has on Steam in your country. It is displayed as 12+ the way I access it.
Same here it seems.
The intent or artistical value is not considered in this. If there are pixel boobs, on Itch, it is 18+. If the developer did not mark it as sensitive, some complainer will complain.
Unfortunately, no. I don't believe there would be a perfect way to address all preferences as previously established. It is still a sub-optimal solution. I'd just take it over what we currently have. That or a site content split. I'm ok with either one, really...
I've noticed that you have been around the forums for a while. In particular I noticed the presence regarding these topics. So I'll take your word for it. And some of the advice on a personal level is definitely appreciable even though it doesn't exactly line up with my own idea I have proposed up above.
That being said I am more so speaking in general terms rather than my own self. I can probably stomach it since things are the way that they are and I can figure out on how to narrow down results on a case by case basis. Again though, it is appreciated. Clearly you care about the user experience yourself.
And to put it another way regarding my first major point. Just because you are able to censor out all the NSFW content, that doesn't solve the issue of a bunch of games that might use it for reasons that aren't centered around sexual gratification vanishing also. Like, what about everything that contains sexual content but still may appeal to people who aren't looking for "eye candy"?
All that content is at risk of becoming inaccessible and as a result of that make you miss out on games. This is why some people (myself included) may want to still leave it on regardless.
And not to be neglectful of your input. I acknowledge that preferences are many and it would be difficult to appease every single persons. However, this isn't comparable to such a tall ask. It's more of a QOL change request that everyone would benefit from in my mind.
I also acknowledge that you may have sidestepped some of the issues pertaining to steam browsing by not engaging with the tagging system over there. That's fair enough. I just don't think that should have any bearing on discussions surrounding people that do actually use it and or care about it's implementation.
Sorry, I meant to imply lightheartedness by including the word "joke". Must've been misplaced by me.
Anyway, the main takeaways of my previous comment were that:
1) Dividing the site's NSFW content of the pornographic variety and non-pornographic variety into categories would alleviate most of the issues surrounding it. As it currently is, a lot of crossover exists between the two due to how the tagging system fundamentally works.
2) Steam has a sub-par solution which only really proves that ultimately you'd need to make a separate site for it altogether. Since users are somehow able to label their games "adult-only" on there without either understanding what that means or due to the vagueness of the language itself.
Long story short. The structuring and language used to define what constitutes as adult are problematic and I think Itch.io and so forth have gotten a little too cozy with the site layouts to make any significant changes.
This flawed tag based filtering is present all over, not just itch.io too. You may joke about it here, but having trudged through so many games it's become really frustrating there aren't proper categories. Large chunk of horror games are by quite a few parameters also "adult" games as it is. So following that logic, it'd be better to section off the pornographic variety elsewhere instead of having to contend with filters that can and have hindered exploration for games that merely contain sexual themes. This is also why the steam store has two separate classifications. "Sexual" (by tag only) and "Adult-Only" toggle.
And this isn't to say that it's helped steam, because developers have on numerous occasions marked non-pornographic games as adult-only.