I agree that is a weird way to put it. I'll simplify it as you suggest.
Javierloustaunau
Creator of
Recent community posts
Yeah I've struggled with having a kinda small playtest sample on this game BUT I think the behind the scenes is that it is swingy and I chose to make it 'win more often than lose' if it is gonna swing. I do think I will be adjusting some stuff and giving players less cards in their hands.
2-7 might be a good idea given the 'card economy' and how you can get a lot of help.
Thanks so much for feedback!
Identities are intersectional and they are pushing on many fronts that affect us in one or more ways.
Republicans try to treat xenophobia, racism, transphobia, misogeny, homophobia, the war on the poor, the war on the working class as separate issues.
Many of us fall under multiple categories, queer, POC, working poor, possibly disabled, possibly immigrant all at once.
We need to fight all initiatives they push because they are all connected, rather than choosing battles along individual identities. Already I see a lot of gay, POC and generally liberal people 'defect' to go support anti trans legislature because they consider that to be 'too far'.
All minorities together are a majority, specially if our allies actually show up.
Just to say I hope you do not see me as antagonistic as Im enjoying this exchange.
So my point is that tacos and punk are living art forms and attempts at classification are bound to fail and are generally the sign of somebody being an outsider looking in. In your case it seems like youthful enthusiasm but we always worry it is somebody who is gonna Christopher Columbus our culture like the British company that copyrighted Taqueria and then sued Mexican restaurants... or somebody with no culture selling crunchy ground beef tacos and using their social capital as authoritative white people to redifine our culture as they see fit.
Same goes with underground scenes... there is already a party you just do not know anybody who would invite you yet. We are already networking, doing conventions, collabs. Podcasts, documentaries, workshops, mutual aid, charities, pooling resouces to negotiate rates and discounts, forming syndicates, publishing each others work, providing distribution, apprenticeships, curated lists, educational resources...
I wish you luck but know these things exist, to define them is to shoot and stuff them because you want to own something and you cannot own it while it is alive and free.
So I did read them but there is a lot to paraphrase without tipping into 2000 words so I will try to be succimct.
1) The steps you point out to the searchabilty problem is "use this hashtag" and "use the collection I created" so use itch the same way everyone else uses it. I think we need an external way to browse by using the API because itch struggles with discoverability.
2) I pointed out you where using it pejoratively becaise multiple sections are dedicated to possible pitfalls in indie gaming which would be replicated in underground gaming unless you intend to police which games can remain underground.
3) the various noncomercial examples are the ones offered by itch and similar platforms already. Us in the Pen and Paper space already do free, suggested donation, alternate builds, free SRD with but profit on print copies, print copies at cost but make money from digital sales. We even trade games as suggested, using the existing promo code infrastructure.
4) So what is "this" because as stated underground exists (completely unsigned), the pay models exists, game makers see games as art, the distribution exists, the discoverability exists although I would pay you to imprive it... all that does not exist is a cop to tell us if we are doing underground correctly.
It feels like a manifesto declaring what a taco is, or what punk is, or what is good taste... even the best authority on the subject only has one perspective and it cannot be applied retroactively to 50(?) years of underground games.
Underground is already a thing and Indie is not pejorative, only an elitist would equate it with tech demos and low effort. Not all projects are winners but most are stepping stones.
Reading the manifesto you are thinking of freeware or donationware (free distribution while asking they donate to relevant charities).
Does this serve any purpose other than marketing by appropriating and rebranding what others have done before?
I've thought this over and I think a sparrow could be a character in Mausritter with a very simple caveat: they are able to fly so long as they have at least 4 spaces empty in their inventory. Sparrows pack light but make lots of trips back and forth for things they need.
I might consider a species document down the line.