Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

16-bit Platform Arcade... need your feedback! ;)

A topic by joined72 created Sep 07, 2020 Views: 725 Replies: 21
Viewing posts 1 to 3
(1 edit)

Dear friend,

I just uploaded my last 5° Level of Pinghetto (https://joined72.itch.io/pinghetto). I think the game is at the right level, so I decided to ask for the Community Feedback.

Pinghetto

Pinghetto
What I'm looking for:

1)...Pro and Con of the Game

2)...What do you think can be Added, Removed, or Changed

and more in general, your sincere opinion as Game-Dev and as Game-Player.

That's all! :)

Kind regards.

Fabio

The game is beautiful. The thing i think it is not good are the star attack. How it does not reappears in the level, i end up not using too much the stars, because i do not know whats coming in the next. I also tried the path with no violence, because occurred to me that maybe the conceptual idea is to offer the option with no violence and the stars is meant to gain more points and not to use as a weapon.

I also think when you get hit, you should not restart at the beginning of the stage.

Dear ootc, thanks a lot for your feedback, it's really appreciated! ;)

I'm just working to add check-points,. I'm also trying to find a solution to the "Star-Attack" problem. Do you have any idea about how can use the Star without violence?

PS: I'm also working on the 6th level (with portals)

PPS: from today Pinghetto is available on the Google Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.godotengine.pinghetto

Dear ootc, I just uploaded a new version (https://joined72.itch.io/pinghetto) with the following changes:

1)... 1 check-point added in any level

2)...little changes to better adapt the levels to be played in the "non-violence" path :)


PS: I'm still thinking about how to solve the "Star-Attack" problem...

The path of violence or peaceful, depends what message you want to tell.
Your enemies are cute, they are smiling, they are rounded, they do not look like they are bad. Example, Goomba from Mario universe, they look cute, but they have eyebrows in "V" and sharp teeth, that turn they some kind of bad guy or make us fill that way. Do you understand? Is the shape of the things that also tell stories. That is why I thought "maybe the developer does not want us to kill them", but you give us points to do that. Put something to turn them into bad guys.

The "Star-Attack" also depends how you want your players play your game. If you want that they have a limited resource to choose wisely when to use or smash the button to kill them all.
Mario when he is on Fire form, only two fireballs may be thrown at once. If you want the resource to be infinite, that is an example. If the stars are finite, maintain showing it in the HUD, if they are infinite, you do not need to show how many stars you have.

See, it is complicated. You can choose a bunch of things. The thing that I recommend is try to make the things consistent. 
How your game runs on a cellphone, people play in a short period of time. So make it simple. The average of people who plays in their phones, does not play to think about the meaning of life or what is good or bad. On mobile, put something fun with a short core loop and ads between the game overs hahahahaha.

Just keep practicing and keep it simple.

Dear ootc, I'm thinking of restructuring the basic idea of the game. I think to prefer a non-violence game (as you can see from the enemies). I'm thinking of changing the mission from "get all gems and optionally kill the enemies" to "get all gems and SAVE your friends" (from enemies -> friends). Some friends will be in difficult situations, and to save them, Pinghetto will need to solve some elementary puzzle. It is my basic idea for now, but I need to think about it for some time. I'll update you about the progression ASAP. In the meantime, let me thank you so much for all your friendly support. It's very appreciated! ;)

PS: what do you think about this new idea? 

I am glad I could help.
I like the idea to save a friend getting through the obstacles and puzzles.
You can focus on this ideia. Get "this" to save "that". It is a good loop and then you just can play around with it, when creating your levels.

Here are some videos that I think maybe will help you in this journey of game design:

I'll study the video deeply, thank you. 

I think I need to study more on game designing. 

I'll share my new idea and progresses with you shortly. 

(+1)

Dear ootc, after thinking about it, I decided to try the "easier" route first (at least for the moment), making the enemies bad. I have reduced the enemy size (they seemed a little too big to me) and added more checkpoints to make the game easier. I am also working on a new look for the hero, and I plan to profoundly restructure all the levels (I want them to be very varied and, above all, very fun). I attach a screenshot where you can see the new enemies (the new look of the hero is not yet final). What do you say?


Dear ootc, I made some changes (enemy more bad), much simple levels, new toys (portals), more check-point, a new hero look and now the game is available as HTML game too.

Take a look here:

https://joined72.itch.io/pinghetto

(+1)

Wow. I like the changes. Now your enemies look bad and the game feel more fun too.
I do not think it is bad to go in the "easier" route. 
We need to learn to walk before we can run.

(1 edit)

I would like to ask you that if you have some time, play my game that I posted theses days. I want to know what you think about it. Please hit us with a reply on our post!

https://itch.io/t/963772/give-your-feedback-to-a-whacky-co-op-experience-availab...

Just done! ;)

PS: I ordered this book to improve my Game Designer skill: 

https://www.amazon.com/Theory-Game-Design-Raph-Koster/dp/1449363210/ref=sr_1_1?_...

Do you know it?

Nice game ;)

Thanks a lot! :)

If I can do a question...
what do you appreciate most, and what less?

Hi,

The game is smooth and the colors are vivid. The msx is adequate. The enemies look good. Activating levers is a good idea. The hero does not look that good compared to the other sprites.

Thank you so much for your suggestion.  I'll try to make a new look to Pinghetto asap. Stay tuned. ;) 

cool.eager to seeing the New look 😄

Feel free to vote for my game 'Minimal' if you desire as it helps me a lot.

Take care

Yes, I'll be happy to vote. From today I 'll be able to download it. Wait for my vote for sure. ;) 

Voted! ;)

thanks a lot 😀

Dear oceo, I have make a new hero look.

You can see the new look here:

https://joined72.itch.io/pinghetto

PS: now the game is playable from the browser! :)