Beautiful pixel art! As everyone else has mentioned, I especially love the cat. The furnace minigame seemed to require an excessive amount of repetitive clicking, so unfortunately I kinda gave up on that one. The game had a wonderful atmosphere though. Thanks for including a Linux build!

I love the game and I see a lot of potential in it!!

I think above all else for me:

-There should be some sort of reward systems for finishing jobs

-The Water/Oil minigame seems like the most broken and I think it's because they're bound together ( i.e. Failing water causes an auto-fail even if you win oil)

Wishing you luck during further development if there is one =)

I quite enjoyed this game! Of course there's little bugs and glitches but for game jams that's totally fine.  I couldn't get past the first water mini game, in the end it proved too hard for me (takes moment of personal shame).

I like this litle game !

Some point are not perfect, for example :

- The guidance, the player are a litle lost in the game.

- Some Graphics bug.

-Hard to read

-and some bug who block the game.

But is a litle game, made in 24h, the audio is good, the graphics is good and the principle is good, just some point to review. Gg at you !

The most important thing first... please let us pet the cat. Also maybe let us name our cat?! 

Next are some general notes and bugs I noticed: 

• UI popups or a (optional) guided tutorial would be nice 
• The font in the help menu is hard to read. For titles and banners it's nice, but it's too much for a paragraph.
• Job difficulty levels would be a really cool addition.
  • The starting position and time allotted for each minigame could be a cool way to change difficulty.
• Passing water OR oil vs having to pass both would be nice.
• Bug - minigame arrows don't reset.
• Bug - resolution scaling issue on the grinder wheel minigame occurs on native 4k display with game in full-screen mode.

Things I really liked:

• The artwork is really nice and consistent! 
• I really enjoy that each minigame is different, but not too different. It's enough to keep you on your toes and entertained but not too much that it's confusing. 
• The sound design is great too! My favorite is the tink noise at the anvil :D 
• The start of the game is super smooth. You get the main title screen, hit 'space' and there you are in game ready to play, no loading or additional screens or anything. 
• The to-do list for each job was a nice surprise. After reading the description/instructions on the itch page, I was expecting to have to remember the order to do things on my own and that it wouldn't be in game. Having the little checklist in order is super nice! 

Overall this is a really well done game! Especially considering the insanely small amount of time that was given to complete it. I'm excited to see where it goes as it's developed further. 

I love the pixel art and the idea of having mini-games for each step of crafting! It all had a peaceful vibe, which made it very pleasant to play.

If you ever decide to expand on the game, it would be awesome to see more of a variety of different mini-games for each step, and perhaps increasing difficulty with each job that you complete. I found the water/oil one a bit too challenging - but that may just be because I am uncoordinated, haha! And seeing the result of what you craft would also be very neat. :)

Nicely done!

The minigames work pretty well, so that on Day 2, you already have a firm grasp of the minigames mechanics, making you feel like a proper smith at work.

The pumping of the furnace could've used some visual feedback. (maybe making the bellow move on click instead of automatically)

the game is very beautiful for the time put into it.  The atmosphere is charming and has no critique except for the fact that i cannot pet the cat :'( .  The help screen was very helpful, but I would prefer the help to be within each minigame that reappeared until you succeeded in that minigame.  The minigames themselves didn't give me any feedback on my input, for example the fireplace minigame should make smoke billowing noises each time the player clicks.  My last critique I have is that you don't do anything with these weapons, so why make them.  If I could sell them to customers, that would really make me strive to do the minigames and to do them well.  I might be too picky for a game only made within 10 days, so don't take my critique to harsh.  It was a beautifully crafted game and I look forward to what you guys make next going forward!