Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

Spoilers follow:

Theme: You name drop it in that it's an expanding of the horizons, albeit I can't help but think narratively you undercut that in part given how much of the discourse between the two new friends is built upon a pre-existing shared interest (as opposed to a new one for both of them, if that makes sense).

Story: Cute tale of new friendship, although I had no idea what age they were for the longest time. I felt like I was getting mixed messages, but that may just be me. Living at home with parents but having their own car but working the 9-5 but not having much money but being able to reliably buy games on the reg and own a video game console-- I felt like they were pre-college until it was confirmed this was only weekend activity barring the departure day.

As much as I do love a good Ersatz, there were so many, and I wasn't sure what they were pointing back to, so that lost me in the mirrored specificity. If it was all meant to be within-universe, then it's nice that they all know what these specific elements are, but our knowledge isn't the same, so that makes the scenes bogged down in second-hand tellings of "so and so" is cool. The ersatz points back to the original with a nod and a wink, as a sort of foundation. W/o that foundation, I was a bit adrift.

I didn't like how they initially forced the two into a 1-on-1 convo. I think it would have been fine if they periodically chimed in. These were two strangers. Help make it easier for your friends to become friends.

I was also a bit thrown off by calling things dates, but then it felt like a burgeoning crush, and having the sort of rom-com ice skating moment. It felt kinda like the narrative wasn't certain whether it was supposed to just be friendship or the start of a romance.

---

Story Aside: What does it mean, that there are pet cats in this universe, and that the wolf took umbrage at being called at a cat when he was a "dog"? What does it mean for the two to be on a similar scale species-wise, albeit one isn't sapient like the other?

---

Presentation: I appreciate the CGs you made, the music choices felt apt for the mood, and I liked how you worked that hug into existence. It didn't feel like they were just mashed together (to me) based on the posing and spacing you chose.

Creativity: It's nice to get a non-romantic oriented relationship piece in this space. That usually doesn't tend to be the case.

Overall Thoughts: A sweet tale that got a bit lot in the sauce when it came to how the characters bonded in a way that was recognizable from the outside, but didn't speak to the same depth of specifics to cling onto and make the connections that were? weren't? there.

Well done, nonetheless!

(1 edit) (+1)

Thank you for your thoughts! Once I finished writing, I had a lot of grievances to as how this turned out. There was a lack of planning beforehand, which is an error on my part. I also started writing the novel on the 18th of May, since I didn't think I'd have enough time to start at the beginning of the month. Life got busy for me. I wish that there was more I could have accomplished. 

I wish I had more time to flesh out the characters, and have it more apparent that Callum expanded his horizons. The brief time that this story had taken place was not enough to develop the characters in something that seemed meaningful, at least to me. I will have to admit, however, I was unaware of the theme at first when I started to write, so I hastily tried to weave in the idea of "expanding horizons." Which, is also an error on my part. I feel like I should have had more scenes of Callum not being interested, and pushing the main character away, so then the character development would be more impactful. As I think back on the story, I feel as though it was rushed, and that does not sit well with me. The growth does not feel gradual, nor organic.

I would like to revise the script and take more time on making the story work in a way that isn't as confusing. I will have to agree that the relationship between the main character and the wolf does seem confusing, on the basis of whether or not they'd be friends or lovers. Ultimately, I would like friendship to be the first step, since it would be more baffling to quickly enter a romantic relationship in such a small amount of time.

About the ages of the characters, I also felt like I didn't have an idea of how old they should be, and the ages were made up spontaneously. If I gave it any more thought, I should have left it at pre-college or perhaps, during. At this time of my life where I am almost in my mid-20s, I find myself in the same position, as well as some friends, so I think I wanted to make the characters feel a bit more relatable. I don't think most people would find themselves in that situation at this age, so if there are revisions in the future, I will keep that in mind.

The erzatses of the story could have been toned down a bit in retrospect. I get a bit carried away with coming up with concepts and ideas, so I did have the characters refer back to many non-existent video games in their universe. I didn't put into consideration how it could make the reader feel lost, so thank you again for your input. I felt that if the characters had a pre-existing shared interest, it would have been easier to connect. I often make friends when there's something that we have in common, but I do think that sharing interests with another is also a good way to make friends.

As for the topic of the pet cat, and "pet animals" in general, I like to think in any furry universe I've written, that real animals still exist. I think while I was writing, I had the intention that Callum took some offense to being compared to a cat simply because he doesn't like them. It may have not been communicated effectively.  The existence of real animals, referred to as quadrupeds, in this universe works a lot like how humans and apes exist. The anthropomorphic animals and quadrupeds in universe may have shared a common ancestor and evolved in different ways over many many years. At some point, humans may have existed in this universe, or still do. Right now, that's a mystery to me, but I would like to think on that concept more.

Again, thank you for putting in the time into reading my story and leaving some constructive criticism. Initially I was afraid of what others thought, but I am quite relieved to get feedback at all.  There are many things I would like to change and expand on, but I suppose what exists now isn't too bad.