Lol you're a moderator ? Accepting rape on nsfw games but intervening when people find it abnormal and tell it ? Itchio is the safer website I've ever seen, truly.
We're not arbiters of taste here. You're talking about fiction, which falls under free speech. Unless it involves things that are illegal (for good reason), we let players decide what's okay.
Oh, and by the way: precisely, I'm a moderator. My concern is what people say in this community, not what games they put on the site.
Are FPS a glorified form of murder?
Are urban racing games a glorified form of reckless driving?
Are comics a way to ruin youth?
Is a woman with her hair out tempting men?
There are people who think yes to those questions. And there are even places where the rights of a group are violated by another who believes they are right in their way of thinking.
When I see a game, with X pixels that try to represent a fantasy woman with attributes that are physically impossible to have, with an axe twice her size killing orcs and if she misses a hit, a raunchy scene jumps out. That doesn't seem like rape culture to me. By playing that, you're not inciting or normalizing a crime.
In the same way that playing a call of duty doesn't incite or normalize you to buy a gun and go out on the street to kill your neighbors.
I understand that a group of people do believe that, but in a society that calls itself free, there must be freedom of thought and interpretation and respect for other ideas or interpretations within the law.
I'm not asking you to change your way of thinking, but if you think that a game doesn't comply with the law, you have mechanisms to report them, but discussing your subjective point of view in a forum doesn't seem to me to be the appropriate channel to do so, basically, because you're trying to force your subjective interpretation as if it were an objective truth, something that has always been harmful for a free society.