Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(-1)

Alright, I have some thoughts. This is just my opinion so feel free to take it or leave it ofc. Just commenting cause I find the premise interesting but I'm hitting a bit of what I think is a rough spot. CH2 (I think it's 2) contains some awkward phrasing IMO with the worst offenders being bits of dialog. 

For example, take this passage:

----

“Azaria. My name is Azaria.” She places her hand on her heart and makes a slight bow. “I am a beloved royal musician of broad and alluring talent. It is a pleasure to formally introduce myself to you, >name<.”

Musician? If she’s just a musician, what was she doing at your meeting with the Council?

“Do you need anything?” you ask. “Am I in the way?”

Azaria chuckles. “I think I’m the one in the way of your morning sleep. Though I can’t seem to understand your preference for sleeping in an uncomfortable armchair instead of a bed. Why don’t you move this delightful activity to your room?”

“I just couldn’t sleep tonight, so I fell asleep here by accident.”

The possibility of one’s own death would leave anyone sleepless.

How many hours have you slept? You don’t feel particularly rested, so probably not much.

“If you can’t sleep, you should do something relaxing that isn’t work-related, no?” Azaria asks. “These books are basically a part of your job now, so they hardly count as relaxing.”

----

I legitimately don't think real people would talk to someone like this. Have you ever gone up to someone and dropped a line like:

"I think I’m the one in the way of your morning sleep. Though I can’t seem to understand your preference for sleeping in an uncomfortable armchair instead of a bed. Why don’t you move this delightful activity to your room?"

No shot. It's lengthy, stiff, and awkward, like I'm watching one of those vids of a Redditor who is talking to another human for the first time after 5 years of never leaving their room.  

People tend to speak in ways that naturally cut superfluous language. "Though I can't seem to understand your preference for sleeping in ___" would naturally be said like, "I don't understand why you're sleeping in ___" because it's simply easier & more convenient. Continuing on, more often than not, someone wouldn't say something like, "uncomfortable armchair" because the uncomfortableness of the armchair is implied with the statement itself ("instead of a bed"), as well as being obvious visually (from the character's perspective, the armchair would appear obviously uncomfortable compared to a bed). 

Even the line, "I am a beloved royal musician of broad and alluring talent. It is a pleasure to formally introduce myself to you," is a bit awkward, because normally someone wouldn't just compliment themselves like that without playing it off as a comedic thing (often hinted through tone and expressions). But the problem is that the text gives no indication as to what her tone is supposed to be here, and our protagonist makes no notes on it either. The protag immediately focused on the "musician" aspect, rather than the fact that she just described herself as someone with "beloved... of broad and alluring talent" which is quite the arrogant statement, and should immediately rub someone the wrong way.

Then the final bit, "If you can’t sleep, you should do something relaxing that isn’t work-related, no?” Azaria asks. “These books are basically a part of your job now, so they hardly count as relaxing."

Normally, people wouldn't just add "no?" at the end there. They'd say something along the lines of, "if you can't sleep, shouldn't you do something relaxing that isn't work-related?" putting the "no" component near "should" (making it "should not") rather than placing it awkwardly at the end of the sentence. 

Anyway, just something to consider. Again, it's only my opinion.

(2 edits) (+3)

Thank you for taking your time to write this! I agree that some sentences could've been written better. English isn't my first language, so I'm def lacking in fluency. Sorry for that.

As for Az and the Oracle moment, Az is just like that, arrogant, loudmouth, talking themselves up all the time. They were purposefully obnoxious, as they often are, and I thought it was obvious enough (or will be obvious once you catch them in a different setting). Maybe not. The Oracle just woke up + doesn't care, so they ignore all the empty words and focus on the info their brain can process. I might add more clarification there eventually.

>Have you ever gone up to someone and dropped a line like:
I haven't, but Az absolutely would and did.

>is a bit awkward, because normally someone wouldn't just compliment themselves like that without playing it off as a comedic thing
Az does it semi-seriously because they are arrogant & to put others off, but it doesn't work on the MC. The MC's lack of reaction was a way to show that.

I'd revise the earlier chapters and probably rewrite a lot of things, but I want to focus on writing forward, so I'm reluctant to reread the earlier chapters because I won't be able to stop myself from editing, lol. I'll save your notes for the future use when I sit to edit the whole thing from the beginning!

(-1)

No problem, author. Happy to provide thoughts. 

Yeah I get your point about the character being arrogant, obnoxious, etc. I guess my problem is, expanding upon what I've written already, with the fact that it's entirely uncharismatic. As I noted before, it's written more like an obnoxious Redditor than an obnoxious yet suave person. You get what I mean? And this is an RO, so to me, rather than the reaction being "okay this character is kinda annoying but I can see some charm," it causes a reaction more like, "okay, well, I definitely shouldn't pick any options involving this person, so that I can avoid this painful dialog." Lol.

I don't mean to be too negative or anything, or to repeatedly harp on one point. I'm just trying to clarify my perspective in case it helps during the time you sit down to re-read everything. 

Wishing you success! 

(+2)

Now I understand what you meant. I'll keep that in mind for the future edits. 

Thank you!