This game is cute but I unfortunately couldn't get far as I have no idea why my choices were wrong. I'm trying to give a bow to the elf that has no bow, just like in the tutorial where the proficient axe doesn't have an axe. The text in the tutorial was a bit fast for me so maybe I missed something, but I didn't understand why it was an Axe of Light that you needed. I tried a few bows but don't know how to know which they'd want. I felt like maybe I need to have played DND to understand....
The enchantment that you need to pick is something that they would want/need. For example, the reason he needed a sword of light is because he didn't have any torches to light up the dungeon or a spell that does it. If they don't have any way to heal themselves they might need something that would do that for them, or if they have nothing to eat something to feed them etc. I really appreciate you trying the game!