Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags
(-2)

To The Developer, is this vn still in development? I ask because I am truly enjoying it very much!  
Please dont think i am insulting your work here, its just some constructive critisms I really think you need to look at if your still developing this fantastic story.

The only things that really annoys me is the mc.  He acts like a completely mentally challenged retard.  Almost every time he speaks to a woman he has to hurl insults at them then use the cop-out excuse he was only joking. I have no problem with him doing that a couple of times, but using that almost every single time, just tires me and makes me hate the mc. I get he has problems, but can you please do some more work on him, so he reads more like a normal human being... and love to have more choices in conversations.  for example, the orphanage woman who looked after Alice.

It is non of the mc business....and just because she had to look after Alice, does not automatically assume we should be forced into helping her! the girls are really sweet and after playing through chapter 9 and into chapter 10 i like where you taking Fiona.

Lucy is so sweet and acts more like a human being than them all put together except Fiona, which I truly think you have fleshed out beautifully with her personality and as again with Lucy.  

I love Sandra too, but I am getting really concerned about the way you are writing her. The more stuff she says, the more retarded she sounds with certain things.  She is supposed to the oldest of the sisters there, but lucy the little genius makes her look like a little child mentally.


Sandra mentions she will be exclusive to the mc, I think you have gone the opposite way which really is not fair at all towards the player.  Exclusive means just that.  It doesn't mean she will mess around with Alice or kiss other women, which seems to be alluded to as the story goes on during the first 9 chapters.  If she was exclusive, then she most certainly wouldn't allow other people to touch her let alone kiss her.  You need to go back to her being exclusive only, or otherwise, give us the choice to allow her to be a whore...which your basically starting to write her as a whore with her sisters and mother.  I mean seriously sucking on her mom's tit for fucks sake while her mom is asleep?  That is not the complete opposite from being exclusive and there really is zero reason why she is doing it in the first place, considering she told the mc she was EXCLUSIVELY his!  so why try to make her into some whore?  It doesn't fit with who she is, it doesn't fit with the way she acts or thinks and we know that from the first few chapters.  You need to stop writing Sandra like this, your ruining the story completely by doing it!  Feel free to keep turning alice into the cum dumpster whore she is...i mean that was your intent with her right? i mean let's forget she even has a story about her etc....because everything about Alice is overly convoluted and tired.


The whole point of a vn is to try and hook the reader into becoming emotionally involved with the characters, you do this by trying to make them appear 'real' in whatever story you read.  When you suddenly move away from that or even move away from that immersion over time,  you lose the grip on the story, and that's basically it, people will lose interest rather quickly. 

Listen I get its got to be very difficult to make these stories, without running into the kill them off bullshit, because of a lack of stuff to do with them or you become bored of them, or you want to end the story by pissing everyone off.  The problem is, the main story is fantastic, no problems with it, absolutely non.  The problems I have lie entirely with the MC because you have written him as a completely mentally challenged retard, who has to hurl insults at as many people as can....ontop of asking retarded questions, because really  it seems his IQ level is shockingly low.  cmon you do better than that with the mc.  He seriously needs a personality change urgently.  There is no reason for him to be constantly hurling abuse and swearing constantly at his girlfriends...in real life guy does that, its game over pretty much.  right now, i couldnt care less what happens to the fucktard...because there is absolutely nothing likeable about him....until he starts giving out advice....if he gives such good advice to women...why make act and speak like a fucking retard normally when he doesn't. As a character he is simply not believable one tiny bit.  His behaviour, the way he speaks helps define his personality.  He is like a schizophrenic on crack and other stuff.  Just get rid of the bullshit abuse and constantly swearting,, the utterly retarded things he says.  It completel ruins the story!  I love the story. I hate the MC because he is the complete opposite of real.  Sandra is exclusive but you seem to have fogotten that completely....give us the choice so she is exclusive and if we choose that that, then make sure she is exclusive in everything to the MC not some plaything for other women or her doing it, that really made me quite mad as i was reading.   

Without repeating myself again, this vn needs to some major tlc , and there are plenty of grammatical errors too, which i generally ignored because i know what you meant.  for example...do you want to marry me?   it should be will you marry me? this the correct way to ask someone to marry you. this is because its formal not informal.  so you want to marry is pretty much like asking for the debate on the subject. you need to change it, because it is wrong.  You also kept writing promised.  this is wrong because it is supposed to be I promise.  needs quite a lot of grammatical work before you actually release this vn as complete, and the mc and sandra needs a massive amount of work, such as removing the mindless and retarded insults back and forth..it getting tiring very fast..its like telling the same joke over and over and over.   If you make these much needed changes,  this vn would got from fantastic to mind blowing.  as it stands,  the mc i just cant stand his snarky shit all the time, and i cant stand the fact you seem to have forgot that sandra is exclusive...meaning only the main character interacts with her sexually, and or kissing...you need to get back to that because she should not behave any other way except exclusive. other than that, i hope you take my long winded constructive critism on board and do something about these two characters..because they need fixing big time, just remove the constant tired as fuck insults from him.  and make sandra exclusive as she should be only for the mc ONLY!!


thanks for reading.

(2 edits) (+3)

I don't know what to tell you man, the stuff you point out isn't really something that is bothering me. Sandra and Alice making each other feel good for example doesn't change anything regarding Sandra being exclusive to MC. Same goes for having a threesome with her and alice while she licks Alice. I'm not going to change that because I'm writing this story how I like, if you are too bothered by that then maybe a different game is better for you. Or, even better, you should try making your own game with the stuff only you prefer! :)

as a tl;dr: I'm not going to change anything since it is my game my dude, I read your criticism but the stuff you suggest is not on my mind :).

Also, to reiterate on the Sandra thing: If you are taking the stuff the girls do with each other as "not being exclusive" then you should work on your insecurity. It is a harem where everyone loves each other and the girls only interact on a sexual level when MC is around ( also known as threesomes ).

(1 edit) (+2)

I totally agree with you killer7... I mean Sandra and each and every character rightfully belong at their own place and believe me... Sandra is one of the most perfect wife character I ever saw after I went through like a 1000 of games... I can't say enough about Sandy... She is just... "Perfect"... Throughout the whole story, I could feel how much she changed... Sometimes, I ask myself... Can there really be a girl like her in this world?... Just wow

Man I really really appreciate and thank you for creating this game... I just finished playing this game last week and I still can't get over all these wholesome feelings and right now I am truly missing the super naked ginger cuddle time... I mean I really got engaged in your storylines.... Really appreciate it man...

But yes I agree to some points with sycopter... I too feel that the MC is just getting a lil bit more cockier with the way he is delivering his jokes... It's way too funny but at this point it's a lil bit harsh and annoying... After 14 chapters, at least let the MC gain some wisdom and lessen his stupidity of a pelican... 

And finally... Really really appreciated that you created a character like Lucy... She is another of my most favourite character... A more realistic girl that everyone deserves in their lives... Thanks man...

And yes... The animations could be better but every other things hugely compensate this factor... So truly no complaints... 

Eagerly waiting for the next update... Huge respect for you creating this wholesome game

(-1)

hey no problem killer 7, like i said i enjoy the storyline.  i mean its fine if she isnt going to fool around outside the family.  it shows you ahve put a lot of effort , time and love in your game and it shows.  i really do like it very much. i just hope you are going to continue with it? sorry if you found what i wrote insulting or something, it wasnt my intention.  i hope you keep the story going.  thank you

(+1)

I'm still actively working on it, yes. Next update should be available in a little more than 3 weeks.

thank you killer7, i really hope you can keep this story going for a long time to come. I appreciate your work, and as ive said before, i know you have done this work with a lot of effort, time and love and pretty much everyone loves this vn you have created and i guess i am definitely not alone in wishing this story could go on for a very long time.  I am more than willing to donate to you, if it helps to keep the story going for as long as it is possible. thank you again and i am very sorry about my demands and sounding aggressive, please believe me, that was not my intention. thank you again.

(+1)

Seeing how you're so stuck on grammar, maybe you should look back on your own comment and see how it is interpreted from a 3rd perspective.
You're using a lot of unneccesary aggressive, demanding language like "You need to do this, THIS NEEDS FIXING"

You come across as if you're entitled to make the dev your monkey and have him write you a story exclusively for you.
That barely came of as constructive criticism and more like an insecure, entitled karen brat that demands to speak to the manager.

Let me quote the exact language if you don't understand what I mean:
"You need to go back to her being exclusive only, or otherwise, give us the choice to allow her to be a whore.."

"You need to stop writing Sandra like this, your ruining the story completely by doing it!  Feel free to keep turning alice into the cum dumpster whore she is.."

"He seriously needs a personality change urgently."

"Just get rid of the bullshit abuse and constantly swearting,, the utterly retarded things he says.  It completel ruins the story!"

"give us the choice so she is exclusive and if we choose that that, then make sure she is exclusive in everything to the MC not some plaything for other women or her doing it, that really made me quite mad as i was reading." (this one is quite special, there's actually a lot to unpack about your character here, Killer7 already mentioned it, but it seems really extremely insecure)

"you need to change it, because it is wrong."

See, there's quite a lot of DEMANDS and a lack of constructive criticism.
And I'm not even mentioning all the edgy remarks you make while using a slur that is used to describe disabled people.
To come to a conclusion, it seemed more like a rant, because your insecurity about Sandra not being entirely exclusive made you mad and you wanted to let your frustration out, but didn't expect an answer, seeing how you even backpedaled on the exclusivity of Sandra.
Example: " i mean its fine if she isnt going to fool around outside the family."

When it was: "It doesn't mean she will mess around with Alice or kiss other women, which seems to be alluded to as the story goes on during the first 9 chapters.  If she was exclusive, then she most certainly wouldn't allow other people to touch her let alone kiss her.  You need to go back to her being exclusive only, or otherwise, give us the choice to allow her to be a whore...which your basically starting to write her as a whore with her sisters and mother.  I mean seriously sucking on her mom's tit for fucks sake while her mom is asleep?  That is not the complete opposite from being exclusive and there really is zero reason why she is doing it in the first place, considering she told the mc she was EXCLUSIVELY his!  so why try to make her into some whore?  It doesn't fit with who she is, it doesn't fit with the way she acts or thinks and we know that from the first few chapters.  You need to stop writing Sandra like this, your ruining the story completely by doing it!" this before. 

That is quite a remarkably fast switch from claiming he's "completely ruining the story" to "well I guess it's okay if it stays in the family".
 

Lets agree to disagree on the stuff you have stated, i really have no energy to argue or anything like that with you or anyone else.  My real point was about the manchild mc and his almost incessant insults then coping out with he is sorry,  after so many chapters, its becoming aggrivating, as someone else pointed out above me,  he needs more wisdom and less stupidity in his pelican madness that's all.  

Infact  since iv'e continued on with chapters 10 -14 i have really got used to the way and sandra and her sisters behave much more than i did in previous chapters, maybe because i have actually grown fond of her and I understand the relationship she has with family and i am happy with that now, i really am, it took me a long time to get to this point, but i am there now.  sorry if you where personally insulted or anything, like i said it was never my intention and you where correct i was far too demanding of which i have apologized, i never meant for it to come across as aggressive or anything.

I agree with you 100%.