Alright, I do agree that your OST doesn't really give me horror vibes, but it still was a good listen.
The title theme really did give me Minecraft vibes, which made me nostalgic about playing it in the Xbox 360 (which is broken now and I hope it can be fixed, Java and Bedrock just isn't the same for me ;( )
What did feel quite horror tho was the boss theme. So these 2 themes I really liked. Great Job!
And since you are using Garageband on Mac, for your future tracks, I recommend trying to get VSTs or something for strings, as I feel that the standard Garageband strings doesn't really sound too well, the most decent strings in Garagaband rn would be Hollywood Strings in the Synth Pads. Since I just use the IOS version, I'm stuck with the normal strings and feel quite limited. You're free to feel otherwise tho.