(SPOILER, DONT READ IF YOU WANT TO PLAY THE GAME)
FYI, since you don't want to play the game or use your brain, the MC and Emma (the bully), smooth things out very well, breaking up with their significant others in the progress. You say the MC is such a nice guy, yet you refuse to believe he can forgive someone, and on top of that, you refuse to realize the situation Emma was in. Emma's father never gives her any attention, so when the person she loved (the MC), started hanging out with her mom and sister, she got jealous, and tried to get over it by getting a boyfriend she didn't even like to begin with. The MC always liked Emma as well, even though she was a bitch at times. They both love each other, so he finds it easy to forgive her. I can't say much on Valerie's behalf, because her story isn't finished yet, but she did the wrong thing for the right reason, and in doing such, hurt the MC both physically and mentally. Valerie apologized full heartedly and the MC still hasn't forgave her, and might not, but as you said, he is a nice guy. He already has a sexual relationship with all of the women, and the only one he hasn't had sex with yet is Valerie, and he loves the other 3, all of which have broken up with their significant other just to be with the MC. I can't even tell if what I'm saying will make sense to you, since your grammar looks like something a 6 year old could type with their eyes closed, but hating on something without giving even a minute of effort into understanding it really pisses me off. I normally respect opinions, but yours has no backing, and is built on half truths.
I hope you realize what I am saying here. Play the game before hating it. I'm done talking to someone speaking nonsense, have a good day.