If his Sus-Level is >3 than he remains salty and you cannot unlock the romance. In order to get ALL the benefits of the neutral/good ending, you need Nauxus at Sus = 3 and Axel at Sus = 2.
And that's why i recommend to stick with the Destruction of the Lizard Village and enjoy the Axel bromance. For a perfect MIn/Max Playthrough you need to restart, and kill the Liazard Spy without hesitation BEFORE you meet Nauxus giving you this quest. Maybe try another version of the hero with totally diffrent stats. As long as you got enough END/DEF, anything goes. (Aside from Agility; since the Snow Village Patch Agility has fallen from one of the best to the worst stat.)
Hello remember me? I Downloaded this game on my new laptop. Since I haven't played a long time yet I forgot the things I should do. So I backread here and decided to go with the Neutral route. So one of its part is you need to get the Fear Potion Quest from Salye. So my concern is that I didn't take the Fear Potion Quest since I don't know what that is. I already made a lot of progress without that Quest. My concern is, will it affect the outcome of the route I chose? Can I trigger it again? And what's the Fear Potion Quest.. I kinda skipped dialogues soo...
don't go in older threads, you can make another, read the guide i told you about on the front page, or ask on the server (unless the link doesn't work, then i can send one). It's also written a few messages above you just need to get thane's cloth in the last part of the war and visit the painting in the temple with the emblem bought in the demon city's auction