The "rub woman to unlock more gameplay" gives me nostalgia for Meet n Fuck. The graphics are alright; couldn't figure out how to get the 3rd and 4th grabby tentacles. nvm it was fixed
Viewing post in Tentaculord jam comments
The 3rd grabbing tentacle should unlock as soon as you fuck her anally or vaginally. Oral is not going to work (I disabled that intentionally, because having a tentacle in her mouth disables all the dialog, and I didn't want people to miss out on it).
It was a bit different in the first build I submitted, where it was indeed a bit more obscure. Are you sure you downloaded the new 1.1.1 version?
When you played it the day before yesterday, then you probably played the 1.1 version. Please try the 1.1.1 build, it contains a couple fixes.