As someone who had 150,000 coins in Club Penguin, I can say that this was a very realistic experience. You wouldn't believe how many times I used to watch crappy videos like this, so it felt like a real nostalgia trip.
I like the premise, which was a surprise from the unassuming title. Your attention to detail was very good. I managed to get 144 seconds, which to be honest is a lot shorter than I remember most of them being. I came out of the game with a big grin on my face, which is never a bad thing.