Celesta's cold gave me the feeling of a snowy town the most, making it fun and intimate, just as it should be. Great stuff!

Here we go! (as Mario would say)

I listened very carefully to your two pieces.

I could be wrong, but in my opinion, it took you less time to make Celesta than Wicked-Pine. Celesta sounds more organic, more instinctive. It may be 7/8 (which I count as 7/4, but those are musician geek details), but it's very fluid to listen to. The melody is beautiful, and the syncopated rhythm of the violin and celesta is very well composed. Really, I love this music. You've managed to do what seems to me the hardest thing of all: make music with an unusual signature that sounds "normal". Bravo for that.

Now to Wicked-Pine Wood. Here I heard a technical demo. I'm blown away by all the 7/8 patterns you've come up with. You can tell you've had fun with the constraint. But since you're in explorer mode, you're losing a bit of your artistic flair. But some passages are really good, especially from bar 21 onwards, with that kick-ass medieval atmosphere! The picolo melody is so cool!

In short, it's very good, both technically and musically, but as you'll understand, I have a huge preference for Celesta's Cold.

I think I preferred the snow themed one mostly because I prefer the instrument choices. I also feel like it succeeded at feeling like a 7/8 song more than the forest themed one if that makes sense idk how to describe it.