Play book
Homeward's itch.io pageResults
Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
Concepts & Originality | #17 | 3.923 | 3.923 |
Adherence to Theme | #18 | 3.846 | 3.846 |
Overall | #21 | 3.628 | 3.628 |
Flow & Clarity | #35 | 3.115 | 3.115 |
Ranked from 26 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Comments
I want to preface this by saying, I am not trying to hate. My intention is to give thoughtful, honest feedback so that every story I rate has something the author can walk away from and both appreciate and work on. If I sound rude that is entirely accidental, I'm only intending to give helpful, honest criticisms and praises.
I really liked having a story from the hive's perspective, not many people go that route and I commend you for it. I will be blunt though, I personally got bogged down in a lot of the names and few grammar slip ups here and there made this a difficult read for me. I feel like if this were a full book then all of the names for things could've been spread out a bit and easier to digest, but as a thousand word short story it just made it a hard read. Still, you've got a really cool concept on your hands and I'd love to see it stretched out into a full length story.
Double the allies, double the fun! I enjoyed all the alien hive worldbuilding you managed to fit into such a small wordcount, too. I have many questions about the rat's and human's motives, but I did enjoy how you were able to sell the team-ups that happened without a conversation.
Some nice additive world building for the Hive, I agree not sure of the human's motivation especially since it killed the rat-folk (unless the poison/spray had something to do with it?) since Ksthrak being on the ship seemed deliberate on the human's part, but all in all this could be a great cold start to a larger story easily enough due to its engaging nature.
I enjoyed the way that you wrote the alien hives character. They seemed very organic and alien.
The flow of this story was technically excellent, and I really enjoyed the unfamiliar POV. I think that Ksthrak/Ksthrata's (the name appears to switch halfway through?) unfamiliarity with their situation both helped and hurt the story, however - it would have been nice to have the events clear to the reader even if they weren't clear to the character. After rereading a few times, I'm still unsure of the reasoning behind any of the rat's and human's actions, and unsure in a way that leaves me dissatisfied rather than curious.
Thank you! Great feedback, I appreciate you taking the time to share it. And yeah, the name switch...can't believe I missed that. 🤦♂️
Wow. That was a neat twist. Alien hives and- *cough cough* -oh and humans too I guess.