Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Reddest-Panda

25
Posts
1
Followers
1
Following
A member registered Apr 13, 2023 · View creator page →

Creator of

Recent community posts

Since you asked for stuff to improve on in the Discord, the only thing I really have for you is to pay attention to your usage of dialogue tags/speaker attributions. 

As a note, all the suggestions in this comment are meant as examples how to get dialogue in line with how dialogue tags work. Like Buggritt pointed out in another comment, feedback for stories isn't supposed to be about changing what was written for the sake of it, but since dialogue tags are a technical aspect of writing, examples can be helpful.

Also just to clarify, dialogue tags are basically the part that connects speech to speaker, and that's about all it's supposed to do. As examples:

#"Such a nice house you have there," he said. The 'he said' is the dialogue tag or speaker attribution.

There are also beats, or dialogue beats, to use an action to indicate who is talking.

#"Such a nice house you have there." Thomas lit his cigar. "A shame we have to burn it all."

'Thomas lit his cigar.' is the beat. If you have to make it clear who is talking but you feel like you've used "he/she said" too often, you use a beat. Bonus points if th action you're using for the beat helps characterize the speaker.

In your short, you have tags like:

#"Private Jonan," Ferrin breathed in,
#"Said he saw somethin'," he sucked his lip,

The dialogue tag (if it's not "said") describes the character's speech, so what you're doing here (due to using a comma instead of a period) is basically saying that Ferrin breathed in while saying it. That Jonan sucked his lip while talking. Both of these are possible, but probably not what you meant? Especially talking while sucking your lip can be pretty awkward to actually do, and just making them beats works fine. (Maybe it's also perfectly doable to talk while sucking on your lip and having a cigar in your mouth and I'm just not built for it, also a possibility.)

#"Private Jonan." Ferrin took a breath in. The tip of his cigar glowed red. (Note: if you actually turned it into a beat, you'd probably just say something about him smoking.)
#"Said he saw somethin'." He sucked his lip.

You also sometimes use "Ferrin continued" or "he piped". Just be aware that "said" is very unobtrusive and such an integral part of writing/reading that most readers don't notice it, almost as if it's part of punctuation. Unless it's used every second line, using "said" is perfectly fine, and usually exempt from repetition and less obvious to the reader than using alternatives like "continued", "remarked" or "piped". "Asked" is the other unobtrusive tag that you just use for a question, and, depending on who you ask, "yelled" and "whispered" also count, just because they're very basic. There is an argument that an exclamation mark and the content of the dialogue should be enough to indicate yelling/someone being audibly outraged, but that's beyond this comment.

Back to your short we also have these two examples:

#"I see it in you," Jonan's voice was soft.
#"Do what you will," I flicked a hand.

These two just don't work, because none of these are speech related actions. The first example would work like this:

#"I see it in you." Jonan's voice was soft.
Sounds a bit weird, so maybe something like this:
#"I see it." Jonan's voice was soft. "I see it in you."
or maybe as a dialogue tag:
#"I see it in you," Jonan said softly.

It's not great writing, some people will argue, because using too many adverbs is often endemic of weak writing, but sometimes, especially in the constraint of a 1k short story, that can't be helped.

The second sentence would work better if turned into a beat and put in front of the dialogue.

#I flicked a hand. "Do what you will."

The dismissive gesture almost micro-foreshadows what his dialogue will mean, which is something neat that beats can sometimes do for you, like creating a tiny bit of buildup for a moment.

What you've already done really well was just skipping dialogue tags when it's not necessary. Readers are usually perfectly capable of following a two-way conversation across paragraphs if occasionally reminded by beats or a dialogue tag, and you did a good job of judging when you can just not have a tag at all.

I'll be honest with you. Did any of the examples I listed here cost you rating in the writing jam? I doubt it. Will following any of the advice I gave here improve your rating for the next time? Again, unlikely. This is very technical stuff a lot of people don't notice or care about, especially in a 1k short story submission to a writing jam, but if you want to improve your writing then this is an easy place to start because it's learnable, unlike some other things that are part of writing.

In terms of your story's ratings, Flow & Clarity was your weakest point according to the stats. In my opinion, both were very good. The only reason why I can see you losing points here would be that parts of the story are vague. I know that's by design, and there are enough hints that give you a good idea what's going on, but vagueness, even by design, sometimes doesn't sell well. 

There were also a couple of instances where a comma should've been a period which made me trip up reading once or twice, and some paragraphs that should've been joined, but that's very minor stuff.

In general, I liked how we were introduced to the fact that something was wrong or would be wrong with the point of view character. From the very first line mentioning his eyes we knew something wasn't quite right with him, and I was questioning throughout how much our general actually knew/to what degree he was a willing participant of his situation or not, or if the situation would "wake him" somehow or infect him otherwise. It was a good read, and a short I could easily see as a little snippet in an army book for example.

Good job, and I'm looking forward to your story in the next writing jam!

Really enjoyed how the ending turned out. With a bit more space, Raenas could've maybe been in a little more danger against the beast, or suffer some consequences from basically losing her bike in the middle of wildnerness, but within the word limit this was a very good read regardless.

Thanks~

I guess I dawdled a little with the writing in the first part. Thanks for the feedback!

Thank you!

Yeah, I don't think I'll try this sort of scope again in the future for the jam. It can get very confusing quickly, and trying to make it less confusing eats up words again. Let's see if I remember next time.

Thanks for the comment~

There are ideas for longer stories floating around, mostly from the point of view of some Havoc Change guys snatching knowledge wherever they can, but that's not really for 1k jams I think. I like participating in these jams, but the word limit does get to me, as was probably apparent in this attempt again. Which just means my premise wasn't entirely optimal for the word count, I guess.

Thanks for reading~

Thanks for the feedback~

Seconding Grizl. I reread the first few paragraphs a couple of times to make sure I understood who was who and when I was satisfied and read on, even more new names popped up. :D 

A good read nevertheless.

I can't tell you how much I enjoyed that simple line of "Or... badly spiked". I don't know why. Got a chuckle out of me. Fun writing. I know I should've expected that he doesn't achieve his goal, given the theme of the jam, but I couldn't help rooting for Rookie anyway. Well done.

Poor Arkan. But sometimes, the simple plan of nuclear bombardment is the way to go. Good stuff!

(1 edit)

Great use of the 1k words. Very high quality writing, was a joy to read.

While reading I kept hoping it would turn out to be a heavily modified machine cult character rather than robot legion because my mind didn't want to accept a robot legion character behaving and talking like this, but I guess it's really up for grabs in OPR how they behave or how varied they can become in their behaviour. And it definitely was a great read and the robot was very entertaining.

No objection.

(1 edit)

Part of me would've liked the shaman to survive, only for him to realize what sort of deal she had struck and then have the final controntation be between these two, but no way that would've fit the word limit. Really enjoyed it as is. Made for a very good read.

Enjoyable read. Half expected The One to pull the good ol' "Assuming control" move on the human, but alas, a gecko handing over a miniature pyramid is also good.

My interpretation is that the slaves were infected with some "Infected Colonies" sort of mutation virus, and that this virus is the unlikely ally which would be a fun way to play with the theme.

- loving the irreconcilable clash of viewpoints the two orcs had
- loving the use of the dwarf as an emergency battering ram
- slightly disappointed that we didn't get any reaction from the dwarf after being used as an emergency battering ram

The professor being clueless at the end and telling them to delete the data feels somewhat forced in that moment, but it's still a great read. Especially love the implications of what happened, and that it makes you think about how this will play out in the long run, will they realize during a med scan that there was poison, how is K-7S2 hiding this from the Delta Lab that is supposedly monitoring all of it or did they miss it, etc etc. It sets up a whole lot of possibilities, which is a big achievement for a 1k word story.

Pretty sure, yeah. Want to build a dwarf firefight squad and fleshed out the characters, so if I get around to it I want a short story focused on each of them eventually. :)

Loving this, since that's exactly a hacking attack I wrote for a custom Cyberpunk pen and paper I halfway created for my group last year. :D

Yeah the jackal as a character was almost an afterthought and I just tried to flesh him out at least a tiny bit when I realized that I hadn't really mentioned him at all. The way to get to him was definitely the priority.

<3

+1 on the split, nice structure, and a very cool moment to set the short story in. Got a hard "Does this unit have a soul" vibe from it (due to obvious similarities I guess). Great read.

Sticking to Joanna's point of view more closely could've been nice to experience being hunted and how the others sacrificed themselves from her angle. The chase was still fun to read with the Custodian bullrushing through them and definitely on point for the theme.