Play game
Red Herring's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| Innovation | #18 | 4.083 | 4.083 |
| Game Design | #31 | 4.000 | 4.000 |
| Overall | #42 | 3.847 | 3.847 |
| Audio | #104 | 3.667 | 3.667 |
| Fun | #106 | 3.708 | 3.708 |
| Graphics | #112 | 4.125 | 4.125 |
| Theme | #288 | 3.500 | 3.500 |
Ranked from 24 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
How does you game fit the theme?
You have to avoid linking evidence that leads down a false line of inquiry
Did you write all the code and made all the assets from scratch?
We made all the models, textures, sounds and code during the jam
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Comments
I don't think I'll be the first to say that his is very well made and polished. This has to be one of the better submissions I've seen. Really amazing work to have done this in 7 days. Gives a really good detective in the 90s feel with the fax machine too next to ya. Good stuff!
Really cool concept. Everything felt very polished. I'd love to see more mechanics involving the investigation in the future. The only thing missing for me was music, and the last mission was a bit difficult, I had to restart many times to get it. Nicely done!
Game is well put together, Was fun simulating a detective. Nice Work.
Well polished and great game
I rated too much games in this game jam and this game got the highest rating :D
I hope you add more levels after the game jam ends :D
Wow, this is a great game, fun and it's well polished. Congrats!
Really liked the idea, and the feel of the world is really fantastic, but I couldn't work out how to get the prisoner level to end properly, tried a lot of combinations but they never worked! Maybe have multiple "win" combinations?
What a seriously underrated game! This has one of the best visual styles I've seen this whole jam, and I loved the idea of connecting pieces of evidence visually. The voice acting also a great touch; the whole thing felt immersive! The only thing I might add is a little background music to enhance the tone. Also, the last case was quite a difficulty jump, so I would try smoothing it out just a bit. But overall, this was excellent work, and one of the best games I've encountered in the jam!
This is a very good game. The models, the pictures, the voice acting... However, i encountered a bug when you connect things, you cant remove strings and you get stuck if you connect more than two.
Overall very good game for the time you had.
Thank you for playing! You can disconnect the string by moving the evidence that's connected to somewhere else on the board. After the jam I'm going to make it so you can just click on the string to remove it.
This is honestly so well made. Not only is the concept great, it's also well implemented too. Making links feels intuitive and all the camera transitions are nice. I could definitely see this being expanded to a full game with larger and more complex solutions. Only real issue is it's easy to just try random solutions until something works, but making players actually think and solve the mystery like intended is always a big challenge when designing detective games. One thing I could think of is having more red herring clues to throw the player off.
Seriously though, I am a fan of detective games and this is one of my favourite games I've tried so far in this jam. I'll be following this project if you end up continuing with it after. Good job :)
Thank you for the feedback! I'm definitely going to take another crack at some of the levels now that I have more time to focus on the writing and mysteries. Should have another version up after the jam is ended.
Great game. Very fun and so well done. Hope to see more levels after the jam.
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Cool game! I really like the theming of the stereotypical tacks and yarn, the voice acting was great, and sfx also good. The little touches of animation were really nice, like the corner turning up as you move pieces of evidence around, and the paper going through the fax machine. Unforunately the actual gameplay was essentially guess and check, but that could easily be fixed with some more writing. But great work, and great attention to detail, especially for a jam game!
Thanks for the feedback! I've got a couple of interesting ideas on how to make the gameplay a bit more interesting and force players to really think about what they're submitting but for the jam I thought this would be a bit more accessible for people who just wanted to get a feel for it. Hopefully I'll have time to implement it at a later date if I return to the project.
Really great concept, and the models and animations were really polished. Though I felt like I was just connecting random evidence to see what was written down a lot of the time. I was stuck on the prisoners one, I felt like there was no way to really tell where they went with just the given facts. The end screen said they didn't go to the hospital and weren't found at the flat, so I had no clue what to connect to see what actually happened. Great work though!
Thanks for the kind words! Yeah the last level is kinda scuffed, I'm going to edit it so it's a bit less wack before the end of the jam hopefully.
An amazing game! I love how polished it feels. The voice acting is also really funny, and adds a lot of life to the game.
However I was unable to solve the third one, after like 30 minutes of trying, I'm giving up lol. I'm pretty sure I know which path they both took, and where they ended up, but no matter how I connect these pins, It never works. (this may just be me being an idiot)
Great job!
Yeah the last one is quite scuffed and convoluted because I made it at like 4am. Going to have it fixed by the end of the rating period. Will give your game a go in the morning!
Why does this game have so few reviews? It is wonderful! It's a great entry for a jam, and I had a great time playing detective. Very good job, congratulations!
Thank you for the kind words! Glad you enjoyed playing! I'll give your game a go tomorrow when I'm back at my computer.
very atmospheric game, i love animations, that with red lines is interesting for sure haha but i think puzzles and controls not quite obvious, and i wish there was something more than just making connections between photos choosing by their description, maybe some more narrative elements?
Thanks for your suggestion! We made a game a while ago called Backmask where you had to sift through cassette tapes to find hidden messages. I was thinking that we could smoosh the two games together so players would have to listen to the tapes and rely more on the evidence itself than just the description. Hope you enjoyed playing!
Very interesting game with a unique system. There is a lot that can be done with these mechanics, especially connecting evidence together.
Thanks for playing! I'll give your game a go when I'm back at my computer
Appreciated! One last thing, do you have any plans to expand upon this?
Yeah so by the end of the rating period I'm gonna have a version that's a bit more cleaned up with the last level balanced to be a bit less convoluted. After that I might make more levels, add an overarching plot and maybe even smoosh it together with our other game Backmask if people are interested.
I loved this! the animations were amazing and so was the graphics!!! the controllers were supper smooth. being able to move the different evidence on the board was a great and fun touch. Amazing game! hopefully you continue to work on this game, i would love to play more!
Thanks I'm glad you enjoyed it! Definitely going to maybe edit and add some more levels after the jam is done. I think the last one is a bit convoluted :p
Woah! You guys did an great job building the atmosphere with your models and sound design! I love the low poly style you went for, and I thought the overall aesthetic was really charming! It was also fun moving around the pieces of evidence and linking them together with the string! And the animations with paper going into the printer and the phone being picked up are simple, but effective! Awesome work!
Thank you for the kind words! We're glad you enjoyed it!
Looks like a cool idea! FYI the Mac version doesn't seem to run for me but I hope to try it when I'm on my windows machine
Yeah I hope you get it working! It is a bit of a pain to get the MacOS version working sometimes and apparently even if you do the performance is a bit rubbish. Gonna hopefully fix it by the end of the rating period though.
awesome game! The art is great, the gameplay is unique, I like the concept of connecting the facts in order to draw a conclusion, this game has good replay value , overall I enjoyed playing! congratulations! keep it up!
Thanks I'm glad you liked it! I'll play your game in a bit when I've got some free time.