Wow you really nailed the vibe, amazing job!!!

1. Follow the Ghost - Really nice ambience with panning effects. I like the ocean waves sound you used. It feels creepy but also a little lonely.

2 Coral Town - Some cool flute clarinet duo. My favorite part was the piano feature at the end. I think the high piano notes were better at cutting through the mix.

3. Cephalopod Shuffle Jazzy! - I really liked the choice of instruments and style. Very square-dance like

4. The village atop a whale - Nice Whales :)

5. Dolphin Taxi - Cool sax solo. The running arpeggios and driving baseline give a lot of fitting energy to the piece.

6. Nephropus, King of the Lobsters - Super fitting instrument choices with harpsichord (?) and snare drums giving the piece a very "royal" flavor. One critic--I think you could have made the track fit a bit better with the militant theme. The snare drum is there, but it feels a bit too chill and.

7. Sunken Mausoleum - The sound design is on point. The church bells and choir give a somber funeral feeling fitting for the father.

8. Farewell Father - interesting harmonization. Liked your use of leitmotifs.

overall a Fantastic submission. There was a good mix of atmospheric and catchy songs that kept me engaged; however all the tracks felt like they belonged together. Some great sound-design. The length of the soundtrack is impressive too.

excellent work!

Man... this is probably my favorite submission. Every track has personality and everything fits your game idea! I love the use of whale sounds in The Village a top a Whale, gives me flashbacks to Secret of Mana, the funky bass and sax in Dolphin Taxi Service and Cephalopod Shuffle is an absolute banger! One of the best submissions here ^^

Wow this is a fantastic soundtrack! Everything is either really catchy or extremely atmospheric!

Follow the Ghost : pretty creepy, but perfect for the context in the story! Love the use of strings and sfx here - very cinematic! 

Coral Town : Lovely town theme! Beautiful melody, and sounds really homey...

Cephalopod Shuffle : AMAZING blues track! Came straight out of nowhere, and went instantly into my playlist! I love how lively and silly it is :D

The Village Atop a Whale : Super atmospheric. The whale sounds are an "obvious" but great touch.

Dolphin Taxi Service : This and the last track make want this game to be real so bad, 'cause you have some great ideas here that I'd love to see become real! Another silly banger!

Nephropus, King of the Lobsters : I like how regal and "classical" this sounds, it really sells the vibe. Also marching snare is always a 10/10

Sunken Mausoleum : Another incredible ambient and atmospheric track. Once again, I really want this game to come to life.

Farewell, Father : A beautiful solo piano track, which I always fall in love with. Great uses of Line Clichés, and I definitely can "feel" parts of it in the ost!

This is one of the strongest submissions I've seen so far! Amazing job! Fantastic ost!

Sold almost immediately with the intro to Follow the Ghost. Wonderfully ambient, gentle piano melodies and a plethora of warm, dense ambience woven beneath. No rush to resolve, floating along and evolving as it goes. Some pseudo-TLOU kind of textures in this one, which I dig a lot.

Coral Town feels a little more typical as an arrangement, and that works well after the textural goodness that preceded it. This gives me some J/RPG vibes for sure, particularly some soft Zelda ones. Great job on the orchestration with this - the mix never grows too busy but always has a lot of interesting things going on at once. The inclusion of the piano to carry lead tones later on in the track is genius.

Cephalopod Shuffle is yet another great change of pace. Some percussion to immediately set the rhythm, and then some gorgeous guitar to get everything moving. This is a groovy one for sure. Good job on the bass in this; the walking lines falling into line to emphasize the rhythm is really well done.

The Village Atop the Whale is not only a stunning visual, you've nailed the kind of core sound I'd associate with that. Fantastic choice of voicings in this, and kudos on the articulative piano playing. The woodwinds on the latter half do a great job of gently carrying the listener through the various whale songs in the background. You killed it with this one, honestly - may be my favorite of the bunch.

Dolphin Taxi Service immediately reminds me of something you'd hear on a Dreamcast or Gamecube. Bouncy bass line, solid 4/4 rhythm and a sax to full send it. This is delicious. The various arpeggios in the background really work well here; blurred just enough to not be distracting but the more you listen the more you're rewarded.

Nephropus, The King of Lobsters has that tell-tale regality to it; not just in the melodies and rhythms, but the choice of instrumentation. Trading off the harpsichord to the piano to carry the chord progression with some mallets to handle the lead tones was really clever here and it adds a nice richness to the track as a whole. 

Sunken Mausoleum is gorgeous and is likely second in line for my favorite. Your arrangements thus far have been really good and nicely fleshed out, but I love your take on the more ambient pieces. So easy to get lost in them. Great choice of voicings here once again.

Finally, Farewell, Father is a wonderful outro. Cannot beat having a piano take the reigns and guide you through an experience. Great playing here once again and I love the minimal accompaniment that comes with this one. The modulations in tempo as it plays out is really well done, too. A perfect ending to such a wonderfully varied soundtrack.

Great job, this was a blast to listen to and covers so many different styles and genres - kudos not only for arranging it so well, but mixing and producing it too. Super solid execution on the theme. This is up there for me in the top spots, for sure. Best of luck!

Follow the Ghost: Amazing textures. Nice touch of Dorian.

Coral Town: Early game town vibes. Definitely feel the Uematsu influence. 

Cephalopod Blues: Definitely wasn't expecting 12 bar blues! Pleasant surprise. This track in particular being the battle theme reminds me of Mother 3 or Earthbound.

The Village Atop a Whale: I love this for a water themed town. Definitely whale noises lol.

Dolphin Taxi Service: Groovy! Definitely has that SNES game airship/fast travel theme feel, particularly in that bassline. Brilliant!

Nephropus, King of the Lobsters: Pretty cool character theme. Feels royal!

Sunken Mausoleum: Alright the chords and choir are brilliant. Excellent!

Farewell, Father: Sentimental outro to the OST with some great piano work.

Great work!

Surprising variety of genras along the tracks, you switched between different dynamics and it works. Good job!

A beautiful and sentimental soundtrack that literally immerses you in the game. In "Follow the ghost" I felt like I was sinking deeper and deeper into the water. The correlation of each song with what you describe about your idea of the game is so well executed.

Cephalopod Shuffle and Sunken Mausoleum are my favorites ones. They're absolutely amazing!!

I was wondering what LABS instrument you used

I'd love to see this made into a game♥

WONDERFUL WORK!!

Oh I though this was going to be an ambient album, but no everything is different, you have so many different style even Blues ! My favourite is the first one though Follow The Ghost its very eloquent. Good job !

That is one of the best entries I have heard here! Nice job.

SAXOPHONE!!!! I can absolutely see the game here from the track descriptions. Super good submission and so much done in a week, absolutely insane!

8 track OST where everything sounds amazing and thematic. Yes! Sunken Mausoleum is a big favorite of mine, I loved the work you did with all the bells it's beautiful! Great job!

Such a beautiful and ambient OST. Thoroughly enjoyed this, great job!

this was fantastic. it deserves so many more ratings! i especially loved sunken mausoleum, it's just fire. it sounds strangely like something you'd hear in naissancee. brilliant!

Great variety of colors in this ! I especially like the slower more ambient tracks, specifically  the opener and Sunken Mausoleum I could just straight up listen to on a daily. Great job! 

Really loving the aesthetic! The descriptions fit each song really well too, I can almost see the game already!
Though every song sounds... muffled? If its an aesthetic choice then it really makes it feel more retro, nice!
Especially enjoyed the surf-rock vibe of Cephalopod Shuffle.

Wow! truly formidable choice of instruments and mix between synth and orchestra. I also like the retro mix of the tracks, a little muffled typical of 2D adventure video games. I think the intro is one of my favourites, nostalgic, minimal with a very good choice of sound design  Cephalopod Shuffle it has a rhythm that I don't know why reminded me of jetpack joyride (very high level composition). that synth sound similar to the sounds of a whale in The Village Atop a whale is still very original and beautiful. nice work and nice submission. 

That's such a great submission. This is the kind of soundtracks that can make one both laugh and cry - it actually almost had both those effects on me. It really shows how much effort you put into creating a whole world, i mean damn, it literally made me think "I wish I put more time into my world concept". You can even grasp each time a real bit of story just by the title and the first few notes. Amazing.

My personal favorites : The Village Atop A Whale and Dolphin Taxi Service, the ones reponsible for the most of my emotions. The latter reminded me of the track that plays in Pokemon Emerald when you take the old man's boat, nostalgia hit hard.

Great!

This is a great submission! You really leaned into the picture prompt and succeeded in illustrating it musically! Especially liked the way you use wind instruments and the piano. Superb job!