Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

I will give you 2-3 paragraphs of constructive feedback(NOT Rate for Rate)

A topic by lkjNsiudy78ay98qmi3p4nskj created Feb 21, 2023 Views: 2,463 Replies: 60
Viewing posts 1 to 57
Submitted (5 edits) (+4)(-2)

I recently read a post that made me realize the importance of providing specific feedback to game developers. I believe that constructive feedback can help developers grow and improve their games. That's why I'd like to offer my help to those who are interested in receiving genuine feedback(including ones that I have already rated). 

If you'd like me to take a look at your game and provide thoughtful feedback, I would be more than happy to do so. My feedback will include a 2-3 paragraph response on what I enjoyed, areas for improvement, and any issues I encountered while playing. 

The goal of this post is simply to help developers improve their games. Please feel free to share your game's link with me, and I will provide my thoughts as soon as I can. And if you're curious, my game is  https://swagturtle.itch.io/maeltropolis, but please don't feel obligated to play it or provide any feedback as this is not meant to be a rate for rate, but I will appreciate it if you do.

Bit of an update 2/23/2023- 

Moving forward, I have made the decision to focus on providing feedback on only half of the requests for the games. However, the other developer with who I was working alongside with will continue to provide in-depth feedback, and their reviews are actually even more comprehensive than mine. I made this choice because writing these reviews takes a significant amount of time, and I have other responsibilities that demand my attention. With the unexpected influx of requests, there are currently many people waiting for feedback, and I hope that you understand and accept this change in approach.

Submitted

hey i would love to get some feedback on my game. feel free to check it out:

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933662

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1924664

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey! I'm amazed at your willingness to give thoughtful feedback, it's quite noble. I'm trying to do it myself but usually I end up with 1 generic paragraph about my impressions :(
Feel free to check our game: https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932578

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey could you give me some feedback ik about the jumping glitch and that i should pair the character to the platforms is there anything else i could do.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1929069

thanks!

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Will play it tomorrow cos I'll be free. Here's mine

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted (1 edit)

Thank you 

Submitted

I would greatly appreciate hearing your thoughts on Vale.  It's got it's quirks, and in the rush to finish we couldn't squash the performance bug or the note-menu GUI bug.  But notes still close properly with C.

Controls: E to interact with notebooks, C to close notes, Esc to quit.  After reading the last note, the game closes automatically.

We do have a planned update for after the GameJam to provide bugfixes and add a seperate ending with a soft credit roll, but I would love to hear your thoughts on it in it's current state.

Vale (Farewell) by BerryGood Games!

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I love feedback! :D

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933107

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I would like to get some feedback!

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933604

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933672 

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey, would love some feedback on my game: https://swayam2004.itch.io/cyclic-conundrum

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932569#post-7370035

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey you already rated my game but if there's any more feedback you have Id love to hear it!

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933222?after=20

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Thanks!

Submitted

Would love to hear your thoughts on our game! We plan on updating it post-jam as well.

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933498

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://develss.itch.io/shift

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933438

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Thanks for the feedback

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932437

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://sprprogramming.itch.io/the-good-lives

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Would absolutely love to hear that … !

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1931890

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932653

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933231
Please give us your thoughts on what kinda direction you want to see our game take/ what you'd add or change. Much appreciated!

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted (1 edit)

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933279

I know the Web GL version doesn't work so please don't provide information about that in your feedback, and by the way I loved your game

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Thanks so much

Submitted

would love to get some feedback on my game feel free to be brutal
https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933159#post-7375992

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Would love some feedback! We are aware of one game-breaking bug that we missed due to running out of time so when you play don't click the picnic basket or the couple on the beach. Thank you :) 

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933085

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Ello I will try to play and rate your game tomorrow.
Please checkout my game too!
Rate Reborn Tower Defence by RealPotatoCat for Brackeys Game Jam 2023.1 - itch.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://hari369.itch.io/endless-new-run

please feed back 

game name is endless new run, with leaderboard feature.it is a variety game.new game idea.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

hi! could you please play my team game to give us feedback? 🙏🏻 we want to improve our game. thanksss 🥰 : https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933499

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Would be happy to get constructive feedback. Read the  games page please  for known issues and things i couldn't implement :)
https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932821

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey I stumbled upon this, I would love for you to try my game and give me an opinion as you describe it, I'm looking to improve as a beginner and what you propose is exactly what I would need, thank you very much!


Here is the link to my game https://beamymars775475.itch.io/kattie-and-the-chateau

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932084 thanks man!

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

lol ik right?

Submitted

Really appreciate it to hear any feedback
https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933624

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hi! We plan on polishing and releasing full game after the jam ends, so we are in search of all the feedback we can get. The game is https://flavedogame.itch.io/dyin-to-live.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Thanks! :)

Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1926639#post-7379782

Fun memory based skill game, 

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I really want to improve my game design skills, so I would like to get your constructive feedback!

Here is my game: https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1929584?after=20#comments

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Would really appreciate it if you gave our game a try and some feedback!
https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1924958

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://generalpenguin.itch.io/kingline I am aware of a lot of issues in my game already, so I'll list them here in the hopes that it saves you some time:
- Music doesn't loop in some areas of the game
- Dragon doesn't hurt you when it touches you
- Dragon teleports
- Controls are not what they say
Thank you if you do decide to provide feedback on my game, but I completely understand if you can't..

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey, I'd love to get some good and long feedback! Most people tend to only leave short or unconstructive feedback, so I'd love to get some!


Here is mine: https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1932343 It's a plattformer, where you utilize death to make specifc jumps. But beware, while dead, you cannot jump! Here is the trailer, if you are intrested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBcSkm8Ppzc&t=14s

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Would be great if you could give us feedback too.
https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933755

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I am new Dev and had joined the jam to gain feed back 

Here is my game - https://johnathjamesthegreatest12.itch.io/equal-to

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hi, we are looking for more constructive feedback as this is our second game jam and we are looking to learn as much as possible. We really appreciate it so much if you do, however, if you can't we totally understand. Thank you

  https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933138

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

looks like there are tons of people need your feedback, not sure if you still if time. But if you really do, hope you could try out our game.

It's more like a prototype than a finished game. I would love to hear your thought, especially on game balancing.

https://fhy.itch.io/civitas-ortus

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey, could You try my game? (https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1930432) I am still not sure if it's good or not :/

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Can't wait to see what your thoughts are.

https://gamepower-studios.itch.io/fight-for-earth

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1931702

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago

Try my game, I am testing a very simple game concept: 

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933411

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hiiii, This is made in 8hrs. I hope you  like it

https://dsun-42.itch.io/journey-of-life

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1931020

It is my first game I made.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1923375

Thank you for your time!!

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I throw this here and hope for the best. I am looking for validating my concept here https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1923375

I'll also feedback your game tomorrow.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago

I guess you are already overwhelmed with the response, but i would still try my luck here.

Please try my game, its a game created to test a simple yet challenging gameplay concept, and it is one of the fewer 3D games in a jam usually pack with 2D games lol

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933411

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey itd be cool if you rated my game

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1931649

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I'd be happy if you gave me a feedback

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933656

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

Hey! So if you/the dev you're working with have any time, I would really appreciate any real feedback possible to provide.

Most people never go in-depth, I respect that you guys are actually trying to help others.

https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933578#post-7395379

Thank you in advance! Go as in-depth as you want, I'll be only glad.

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago
Submitted

I would love some feedback for mine! https://itch.io/jam/brackeys-9/rate/1933680 (you posted your game on my post like this one a while back and I probably won't get to it sorry :/ I'll try to give you feedback at some point after the jam at least cause I appreciate you paying it forward)

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago

hey boi,

I saw your post and I want just genuine feedback, what you like and what not 🚫,

I don't want to win jam just want to improve myself !!!! 

Thanks !

Submitted
Deleted 1 year ago